Thoughts for the Lenten homestretch

April 14th, 2008 ~ Orthodox perspective

So here we are in the homestretch of Lent. Passing the fifth Sunday, we bear down on Lazarus’ tomb and Christ’s triumphal entry into Jerusalem. The Holy Week services are lengthy, to be sure, but they don’t seem like work. The Church has done the work. The standing, the praying, the chanting, reading, listening, repeating don’t seem like work — they seem like breathing.

But I’m not quite ready to take my leave of the Lenten journey yet. I wanted to write down some things I picked up when Protection of the Holy Virgin Monastery in Lake George, CO came to speak to our women’s group. I’m being selfish by blogging this: it’s really just a way to have it all in one place so next year I can remember it. But maybe it’ll be worthwhile for others as well. You never know. Different journeys — one destination.

.
article-divider.jpg

The Ladder of Divine Ascents — “Don’t read this book!”Mother Cassiana had a strong word of warning for us all that I’ve never heard anyone say before — “Do NOT read ‘The Ladder of Divine Ascents.’

I know that that is far from being a consensus opinion in the Orthodox world. (Father Thomas Hopko, just to name one, has a podcast on Ancient Faith Radio where he extols the virtues of the book and says that laity can read it.) And lest I inadvertently scandalize anyone, I hasten to add that her warning may have been meant specifically for lay-women. But in any case, when she gave her reasons I could see her point. I pass it along in case it’s a word of wisdom for anyone else.

Mother Cassiana said that she’s seen terrible damage done in this country by people reading a book that was written BY a male monk FOR male monks and then trying to have the same experience in their very different circumstances. She was particularly adamant that women should not try to have the same relationship with a spiritual father that St. John Climacus outlines for monks in the Ladder.

So is that shocking? Maybe. But boy, do I find myself agreeing with her. I haven’t seen the disastrous results that she has, and I’ve never tried to read the Ladder (the “easy reader” version called “Ascending the Heights” was more than enough to convince me that I wasn’t ready for the big time.) But in my VERY paltry attempts to manufacture the degrees of holiness that I can read about in Orthodox books, I’ve gotten myself into some pretty unholy messes. It’s very, very easy to delude yourself both about how well you’re doing and how poorly you’re doing. It’s taken some spiritual counseling to work through both of those extremes.

And looking outward, I see that others have issues as well. I recently read a book called “Short Trip to the Edge” about an Orthodox convert — involved in his Greek Orthodox Church here in Missouri — who went to Mt. Athos on several trips as a personal pilgrimage to find a spiritual father. Now, this is a good book for anyone who wants to hear the services on the Holy Mountain described, as well as its scenery and people. But I found myself drawing further and further away from the author, especially as his successive trips met with a firm but gentle ‘no’ from the monks he encountered. One of the monk-priests that he had been secretly hoping would be “The One” told him point-blank: “You need to find someone closer to home.” So why didn’t he listen? I have a feeling it was because of the sort of thing that Mother Cassiana talked about. We American converts can so easily get into a kind of gray area where we say, as St. Zosimas did before meeting Mother Mary: “Is there a monk on earth who can be of use to me and show me a kind of asceticism that I have not accomplished?”

So I think Mother Cassiana is onto something. There may be great benefits to reading this jewel of ascetic instruction, but there are also hidden risks. It seems more humble to just read any short excerpts that come your way (or any that your priest gives you to read) but understand that there are some things that are just too much for most of us to handle.

.
article-divider.jpg

.
The themes

Mother Cassiana got into so many topics I wouldn’t have been able to name them all, let alone take notes. But I was particularly interested in her breakdown of the themes of the Sundays of the Lenten Triodion. Here’s a very distilled version:

  • Sunday of Zaccheus — Desire. Do I have the desire to meet Jesus Christ? What would I be willing to do for the Kingdom of Heaven?
  • Sunday of the Publican and the Pharisee — Humility. Do I have the humility to undertake the Lenten journey?
  • Sunday of the Prodigal Son — Repentance. Am I willing to come to my senses, to really repent of my sins?
  • Sunday of the Last Judgment (Meatfare Sunday)– Do I remember that we will all be judged?
  • Sunday of Expulsion from Paradise (Forgiveness Sunday) — Godly sorrow. Do I realize what I have squandered? Do I remember where I came from?
  • Sunday of Orthodoxy — Obedience to the Church.
  • Sunday of St. Gregory Palamas — Prayer. We can recover the Uncreated Light — how can I make my whole life a prayer?
  • Sunday of the Holy Cross — Encouragement. This is the very Tree of Life from Eden.
  • Sunday of St. John of the Ladder — Acquiring virtues. The virtues are acquired one at a time to those who struggle for them.
  • Sunday of St. Mary of Egypt — The fruits of repentance. It is possible! The worst sinner can enter the Gates of Paradise if they truly repent. (Mother Cassiana pointed out that the fifth week of Lent is also the week the entire Akathist hymn is sung in order to put the example of the Theotokos before us as well.)

8 Responses to “Thoughts for the Lenten homestretch”

  1. DebD Said:

    This was very good stuff. I have also been told (and heard in other places) that laypeople should not be read “The Ladder…” - especially new converts (like myself). I’ve also seen (and heard) some of the consequences for those who did not heed their spiritual father’s advice and have stayed away.

  2. Mimi Said:

    I have also heard the same thing about The Ladder and have not read it (although there is a book that parses the information for laypeople that looks good)

    What a wonderful retreat, thank you for your notes!

  3. s-p Said:

    Amen Amen Amen. I’ve dealt with so many goofy googly eyed deluded vainglorious humbly arrogant monkabee converts…. don’t get me started. This post should be a billboard at the entrance to every Orthodox Church.

  4. Tanya Said:

    Thank you - Mother Cassiana’s reasoning makes sense. I could easily see myself falling into this state that Steven describes above…

  5. Grace Said:

    s-p:
    I think we start simple. Say, a t-shirt in bright colors that says “Don’t be a monkabee.” It gets issued right away to anyone who gets mad that everyone else isn’t fasting strictly enough.

    My expression for the same thing is “Orthodoxier than thou.” And the irony, of course, is that those that were the most Orthodoxier than thou now aren’t Orthodox at all.

  6. Grace Said:

    Tanya:
    It’s a humbling thing to have to admit. I’m afraid that my inclination may be to have erred in the opposite direction, trying so hard to avoid shallow acts of pietism that I don’t apply myself to the “hard stuff” nearly vigorously enough.

    May God have mercy on both our struggles.

  7. Christopher Orr Said:

    I used the themes of the Sundays of the Triodion in my own lenten homily this past weekend. I posted it here:

    http://orrologion.blogspot.com/2008/04/pan-orthodox-vespers-lehigh-valley.html

  8. s-p Said:

    YES, read Christopher’s homily! And yes, Grace, I have a whole line of “monkabee products” we could sell. Also check out Benedict’s youTube
    “How to be not very Orthodox” if you haven’t already
    http://benedictseraphim.wordpress.com/2008/04/09/how-to-not-be-very-orthodox-a-public-service-announcement/

Leave a Reply


Bad Behavior has blocked 170 access attempts in the last 7 days.